A heartbroken psychotic wearing a watch jeweled with kryptonite abducts Chloe and Jimmy and subjects them to a polygraph; while searching for them, Clark and Lois pose as a couple.

Clark learns that John Jones was shot while working as a police officer; Lana tells Tess that Lex isn't the man she thinks he is, forcing Tess to re-evaluate her position as head of Luthercorp.

At Chloe’s birthday party, a mysterious magician named Zatanna grants Chloe’s wish to be more like Lois and switches the two into each other’s bodies. Zatanna searches for her father’s book of spells so she can conjure up his spirit but not before also granting Clark his deepest wish.

Tess forces Oliver to come to a Queen Industries gala to put the Board at ease, but things go awry when the Toyman shows up with a bomb and a plan to take revenge on Oliver. The Toyman tells Oliver he must confess to murdering Lex or he will blow the place up. Meanwhile, as part of his training, Jor-El gives Clark the ability to hear other people’s thoughts.

Clark meets Zatanna at a comic book convention, where she tells him her father charmed a copy of the comic book "Warrior Angel" and it holds magical powers. A young man named Stephen steals the comic book and develops super powers, transforming himself into Warrior Angel and saving Chloe from a horrible accident.

Clark aktiverar av misstag en kryptonisk låda, som tidigare tillhört Lioner Luthor, och skickas därefter till ett alternativt unversum. Samtidigt tar sig den mordiske Clark Luthor in i Clarks universum för att ta hans plats.

Desaads underhuggare kidnappar Chloe och Oliver, som de tror är FBI-agenter på jakt efter deras dödsbringande ledare. När Desaad inser vem det är han har fångat, försöker han övertala Chloe att byta sida.

Clark och Lois besöker Jor-El för att få hans välsignelse och han låter Lois ta över Clarks superkrafter för att hon ska få inblick i hans liv. Men snart tvingas Lois använda dessa krafter för att strida mot Toyman som plötsligt återvänder.