Nathan makes a desperate play to protect Mara from the furious citizens of Haven, leaving Dwight and Duke to deal with a deadly trouble that threatens to burn the town to the ground.

Dwight and Nathan clash over what to do about Mara; Dwight wants her to end the troubles at any cost, but Nathan is convinced that Audrey is in there.

A paranormal trouble tears Audrey and Nathan apart just after they were reunited.