在“爱你，西蒙”事件发生一年后，维克托和他的家人从德克萨斯州搬到亚特兰大溪木镇，期待开始新生活。在冬季嘉年华会上，维克托看到了米娅和公开出柜的本吉，他想融入其中，决定和米娅一起乘摩天轮。

在与米娅一起乘摩天轮的消息传开后，维克托意外地受到欢迎，米娅开始对他产生感情。维克托开始在当地的一家咖啡店工作，本吉也在那里工作。维克托与米娅共度温馨时刻，并告诉西蒙他可能喜欢米娅。

维克托决定弄清楚自己的感受，于是他带米娅去一个艺术展览约会，他们在那里初吻。维克托和米娅赶上乐队之战的结尾，而维克托对本吉的迷恋在观看他的表演后变得愈加强烈。然而，本吉有个叫德里克的男友。

维克托和皮拉进一步了解罗杰一事。在一场篮球比赛中，维克托与父母对峙罗杰一事，并得知阿曼多已经知道这件事。皮拉和维克托得知他们从德州搬家是为了帮助父母从出轨中恢复过来，感到很震惊。

家中情绪紧绷，维克托希望能有所缓和，所以举办生日派对。西蒙告诫维克托多为自己抽时间，而维克托表示他希望认清自我。维克多的祖父看到本吉和德里克接吻，这激怒了他。维克托和伊莎贝尔支持本吉。

当米娅说她想更进一步时，维克托感到很紧张。本吉即将与德里克交往一周年。蕾可暗讽维克托是同性恋，因此他试图强迫自己与米娅发生性关系。西蒙劝告维克托他别再“迷恋”米娅，在伤人伤己前尽早结束一切。

维克托和本吉在城外进行了一次出乎意料的公路旅行。维克托与本吉在汽车旅馆过夜。维克托亲吻了本吉，本吉将其推开，因为他仍和德里克在一起。维克托向西蒙发短信，鼓起勇气向西蒙出柜。本吉建议他们不要谈论那一吻。

维克托去拜访西蒙，一探纽约的开放程度。在变装派对上，西蒙的朋友不小心说漏嘴，他们都知道他和本吉两人的情况。西蒙出现并向其解释说，他需要朋友的指导才能帮他充当他的人生导师。西蒙等人表示他们永远在这里，永远接受他。

回到亚特兰大后，维克托开始向他的朋友们敞开心扉，向菲利克斯出柜。维克托得知本吉会在其他地方工作。西蒙建议给本吉写封信，渴望得到谅解。皮拉在维克托的背包里找到了写给B的信，却没有意识到是写给本吉的。

维克托决定给米娅留下一个完美的夜晚，带她去了春季舞会。本吉和德里克分手。本吉与维克托接吻，承认对彼此的感情，而米娅见证了一切。维克托向本吉保证会向所有人出柜。父母宣布要分居，维克托毅然决然向父母出柜。

As summer break comes to an end, Victor grapples with his family’s reaction to his coming out.

Back at school, Victor starts to lose his nerve about telling everyone he and Benji are a couple.

Now out at Creekwood, Victor faces some unexpected resistance from his basketball teammates.

On a weekend getaway, Victor and Benji hope to take their relationship to the next level.

Victor feels unsure of his place at Creekwood after quitting the basketball team.

Pilar's new friend Rahim reaches out to Victor for guidance. Victor and Isabel reach a boiling point.

Victor discovers a surprising secret Benji's been keeping.

After a confrontation with Isabel, tensions rise with Benji and Victor. Mia learns troubling news.

Feeling overwhelmed by his troubes, Victor cuts school with Rahim to let off steam.

At Harold's wedding, Mia makes a bold decision, while Victor and Felix consider their futures.

Victor makes his choice between Benji and Rahim. Mia and Andrew reunite with her estranged mother to get answers. Felix and Pilar begin their new romance, while Lake and Lucy spend the night getting closer.

Victor tries to mend the fallout from his love triangle. Mia throws a party to take her mind off the fact that she might be moving. Felix and Lake achieve closure from their breakup. Isabel finally attends a PFLAG meeting, which doesn't go as planned.

Victor's parents introduce him to a gay-friendly church and an exciting new friend. Mia questions how she fits into Lake's new relationship. Felix learns that his mom is starting to date. A new secret of Benji's causes friction between him and Rahim.

Victor is enjoying the steaminess of his relationship until an unforeseen complication makes him reconsider. Lake pawns Mia off on Georgina for the day. Armando catches Pilar and Felix canoodling. Rahim begins to tutor Benji.

Attempting to move on from his past relationships, Victor goes on an unexpected adventure. Felix and Pilar struggle to maintain their relationship after the fallout from Isabel and Armando. New information has Benji revisiting moments from his past.

Victor tries to help a closeted classmate. Mia gets a startling call from her father. Armando and Isabel disagree about how to discipline Pilar. Lake discovers some upsetting news about Lucy. Rahim's uncle creates family drama.

Victor is conflicted about accepting an award at school. Felix and Lake confide in each other about their relationship problems. Mia and Andrew travel to see her family, which raises questions about their futures.

The Winter Carnival brings all of our characters back to where the series started. As they consider their plans past high school, they each have decisions about who they want to be with, and where their futures may lead.