A religious prostitute who sees an atheist client die after blaspheming believes the next man she runs into is Jesus.

In the small town of Eden, Tennessee, a neglected and naive teenage girl named Clara Banks has made a habit of deceiving people online for gifts, a gambit known as "catfishing." She thinks it's all fun and games until she hooks the attention of the wrong person. A short time later, events set into motion spiral out of control as someone begins stalking Clara and her friends. As the consequences of her actions return to haunt her, twisted messages start showing up at Clara's home, causing her to fear for her life. Will she ever feel safe again now that the evil has come knocking?

When Jacob tells Jesus that Lazarus, his son, is dead, he goes to his house to raise him from the dead.

A woman is persecuted by Jesus freaks after they've crucified her preacher husband.